International Standards and Conformity Assessment for all electrical, electronic and related technologies

TC 72

Automatic electrical controls





Approval %
12 12 100 >=66.7% APPROVED


Number of


approving and

17 7 >=4 (if <=16)
>=5 (if >=17)

 Illustration: Voting

Voting Result


Document 72/1165/NP


Project : IEC 60730-2-23 ED1

PNW 72-1165: Automatic electrical controls - Part 2-xx: Particular requirements for electrical sensors and sensor elements


Reference Circulation date Closing date Downloads
72/1165/NP 2018-12-07 2019-03-01
Compilation of Comments
CC file    
export to xls file

Result of Voting

Austria O 2019-03-01 A N -
Belgium P 2019-02-28 A N -
Bulgaria O -
Canada P 2019-02-15 Y Y Y -
China P 2019-02-18 Y Y N Y
Croatia O -
Czech Republic P 2019-02-27 Y Y N -
Denmark P 2019-02-06 Y Y N -
Finland P 2019-02-25 A N -
France P 2019-02-21 A N -
Germany P 2019-02-25 Y Y Y Y
Greece O 2019-03-01 Y Y N -
Hungary O -
India O -
Italy P 2019-02-28 Y Y Y Y
Japan P 2019-03-01 Y Y Y -
Korea, Republic of O -
Mexico - 2019-03-01 - Y N -
Netherlands P 2019-02-26 A N -
New Zealand O -
Norway P 2019-01-23 A N Y
Pakistan P 2019-02-25 Y Y N -
Poland O -
Portugal - 2019-03-01 - N -
Qatar - 2019-02-26 - Y N -
Romania O 2019-03-01 Y Y N -
Russian Federation P 2019-02-27 Y Y N -
Slovakia O -
South Africa O -
Spain O 2019-02-25 A N -
Sweden O 2018-12-13 A N -
Switzerland P 2019-01-24 Y Y Y -
Ukraine O 2019-03-01 Y Y N -
United Arab Emirates - 2019-02-24 - N -
United Kingdom P 2019-02-08 Y Y Y -
United States of America P 2019-02-26 Y Y Y -


The final result of voting will be indicated in the Report of Voting (RVN), as P-members have the possibility to nominate an expert one month after the closing date -- complete information in AC/172/2000

  1. Approving: Does the National Committee approve the addition of the new proposal to the program of work of the committee [Yes/No] ?

  2. Only votes received from P-members before the closing date are counted in determining the decision.

  3. P-members not voting: (0)

  4. CD/CDV: Does the National Committee agree with direct submission of the draft accompanying the proposal as a Committee Draft/Committee Draft for Voting [Y if Yes] ?

  5. Participation : Is the National Committee prepared to participate in the development of the project [Yes/No] ? (Only those voting in favour of the proposal itself have their willingness to participate considered as part of the final decision.)

  6. Acceptance criteria for TS/IS:

    • approval of the work item by a 2/3 majority of the P-members voting

    • at least 4 P-members in the case of a committee with 16 or fewer P-members, or at least 5 P-members in the case of committees with 17 or more P-members, have nominated or confirmed the name of an expert and approved the new work item proposal

*Comments rejected because they were not submitted in the IEC Comment form.
**Vote rejected due to lack of justification statement.